Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

History magazine - researches
Reference:

Bogdanov V.P. The Old Believers' Booklore and Old Believers' books in the 20th-21st Centuries: on the Material of Polemical Works

Abstract: The study continues the author's research in the field of the Old Believers' booklore. The widespread interest in this topic is founded primarily by the fact that the Old Believers' culture in many ways grew out of a careful treatment of the ancient book. The general reasons for the topic's development are formulated in the works of N. Y. Bubnov, N. S. Guryanova, I. V. Pozdeeva, N. N. Pokrovsky and others. At the same time, many studies are of a descriptive nature. The suggested by O. N. Bakhtina and E. E. Dutchak approach ("social archaeology") has allowed to tie the questions of the use of one or other monuments by the social environment in which they existed. In the presented article, based on the principles of this approach, the author attempts to trace the changes in the reading circle of the Old Believers in the 18th - 21st centuries. In contrast with the previous article, which was based on an analysis of the content of Old Believers' libraries in the second half of the 20th - 21st centuries, this new work is based on the polemical texts of the Old Believers. To these one can rather conditionally call upon not only the works written as a reaction to the leading discussion, but also the texts of the Old Believers on the history of their agreements. As a rule, the latter were written also as part of a polemical discussion with their opponents. On the basis of the polemical works of the 20th century, created primarily in South Vyatka and Verkhokamye, on the information of field diaries, the author traces the fates of Old Believer scribes and reconstructs their collection of reading. The article shows the transformation of the relationship of different generations of tradition-bearers towards polemical monuments composed by their fellow believers and their perceptions of the information contained in them.


Keywords:

polemical literature, Old Believer faith, Old Believer booklore, reading, expeditions, Verhokamye, South Vyatka, tradition, change, archaeography


This article is unavailable for unregistered users. Click to login or register

References
1. Smilyanskaya E.B. Knizhnaya premudrost' i izbranie puti spaseniya staroobryadtsami Verkhokam'ya na rubezhe XX—XXI vv. // Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Istoriya. 2013. ¹ 1(21). S. 36—43.
2. Semibratov V.K. Starovery-fedoseevtsy Vyatskogo kraya. M.: Arkheodoksiya, 2006. 204 s.
3. Rogozin P.I. Sushchestvuet li zagrobnaya zhizn'. Korntal', 1968. 185 c.
4. Pochinskaya I.V. Istoriko-polemicheskiy sbornik filippovtsev Yuzhnoy Vyatki // Pravoslavie v sud'be Urala i Rossii: istoriya i sovremennost'. Ekaterinburg: IIA UrO RAN; Izd-vo Ekaterinburgskoy eparkhii, 2010. S. 244—247.
5. Pavlov A.S. Kurs tserkovnogo prava. Sergiev Posad, tip. Sv.-Tr. Sergievoy Lavry, 1902. 552 s.
6. Pavlov A.S. Nomokanon pri Bol'shom Trebnike: ego istoriya i teksty, grecheskie i slavyanskie, s ob'yasnitel'nymi i kriticheskimi primechaniyami. M., 1887. 553 s.
7. Materialy k istorii staroobryadchestva (dokumenty iz arkhiva L.A. Grebneva): sbornik dokumentov / Otv. red. V.P. Bogdanov. Izdatel'stvo "Pero", 2016. 236 s.
8. Materialy k istorii staroobryadchestva Yuzhnoy Vyatki (po itogam kompleksnykh arkheograficheskikh ekspeditsiy MGU imeni M. V. Lomonosova). M.: MAKS Press, 2012. 308 s.
9. Materialy k istorii staroobryadchestva Verkhokam'ya: po itogam kompleksnykh arkheograficheskikh ekspeditsiy istoricheskogo fakul'teta MGU imeni M.V. Lomonosova: sbornik dokumentov. M.: MAKS Press, 2013. 276 s.
10. K istorii knizhnoy kul'tury Yuzhnoy Vyatki: polevye issledovaniya : po materialam arkheograficheskikh ekspeditsiy 1984—1988 gg. SPb.: BAN, 1991.
11. Mal'tsev A.I. K istorii sozdaniya fedoseevskogo sbornika postoyannogo sostava «Otecheskie zaveshchaniya» // Staroobryadchestvo: istoriya, kul'tura, sovremennost'. Materialy VII Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii / Red.-sost. V.I. Osipov. V 2-kh t. M., 2005. T. 2. S. 134–141.
12. Dutchak E.E. Staroobryadcheskaya kniga: "bolevye tochki" nauchnogo opoznaniya pozdney kirillicheskoy rukopisi // Yazyk, kniga i traditsionnaya kul'tura pozdnego russkogo srednevekov'ya v zhizni svoego vremeni, v nauke, muzeynoy i bibliotechnoy rabote XXI v. M.: MGU, 2011. S. 674-689.
13. Dokazatel'stvo sushchestvovaniya Boga na primere poryadka vo vselennoy. Novozybkov, 1993. 78 s.
14. Dutchak E.E. Iz "Vavilona" v "Belovod'e": adaptatsionnye vozmozhnosti taezhnykh obshchin staroverov-strannikov (vtoraya polovina XIX v. — nachalo XXI v.). Tomsk: Izd-vo Tom. un-ta, 2007. 414 s.
15. Gur'yanova N.S. Staroobryadtsy i tvorcheskoe nasledie Kievskoy mitropolii. Novosibirsk, 2007. 378 s.
16. Gradoboynova E.V. Rol' kirillicheskikh pechatnykh izdaniy v formirovanii mirovozzreniya staroobryadtsev-bespopovtsev // Yazyk, kniga i traditsionnaya kul'tura pozdnego russkogo srednevekov'ya v zhizni svoego vremeni, v nauke, muzeynoy i bibliotechnoy rabote XXI v. M.: Izd-vo MGU, 2011. S. 610—624.
17. Vorontsova E.V. Ustnoe bytovanie dukhovnykh stikhov v srede sovremennykh staroobryadtsev Yuzhnoy Vyatki // Antropologicheskiy forum. 2014. ¹ 23. S. 38—51.
18. Bogdanov V.P. Yuzhnovyatskaya arkheograficheskaya ekspeditsiya Moskovskogo universiteta: itogi i perspektivy // Istoricheskiy zhurnal: nauchnye issledovaniya. 2016. ¹ 4. S. 414-425.
19. Bogdanov V.P. Staroobryadcheskaya knizhnost' i staroobryadcheskie knizhniki XX-XXI v.: na materiale chastnykh bibliotek // Istoricheskiy zhurnal: nauchnye issledovaniya (v pechati)
20. Bogdanov V.P. Pis'mo M.A. Basalaeva v kontekste istorii staroobryadchestva Yuzhnoy Vyatki // Staroobryadcheskaya kul'tura i sovremennyy mir. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov i materialov. T. 7 / Otv. red. i sost. S.V. Taranets. Kiev: tipografiya "Vipol", 2016. S. 192-199.
21. Bakhtina O.N., Dutchak E.E. Ot "knigi chitaemoy" k "cheloveku chitayushchemu": iz opyta raboty arkheograficheskoy ekspeditsii Tomskogo universiteta (1986—2006) // Traditsionnaya kniga i kul'tura pozdnego russkogo srednevekov'ya. V 2 ch. Ch. 2. Yaroslavl': Remder, 2008. S. 285—300.
22. Arkhiv Mezhkafedral'noy arkheograficheskoy laboratorii (dalee AMAL). F. Yuzhnaya Vyatka. Dnevnik A. Iserova, 2003.
23. AMAL. Dnevnik V. Bogdanova, 2011.
24. AMAL. Dnevnik N. Vysotskogo, E. Yagodkinoy, 2011.
25. Bakhtina O.N. Kirillicheskaya kniga: sovremennye aspekty vospriyatiya i izucheniya // Yazyk, kniga i traditsionnaya kul'tura pozdnego russkogo srednevekov'ya v zhizni svoego vremeni, v nauke, muzeynoy i bibliotechnoy rabote XXI v. M.: Izd-vo MGU, 2011. S. 666—674.
26. Ageeva E.A., Yukhimenko E.M. Krasnyy ustav // Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya. T. 38. M., 2015. S. 481-482.
27. Ageeva E.A., Kobyak N.A., Kruglova T.A., Smilyanskaya E.B. Rukopisi Verkhokam'ya XV-XX vv. v biblioteke Moskovskogo universiteta. M.: Tsimeliya, 1994. 459 s.
28. Smilyanskaya E.B. «Tri dorogi est': odna v ad v muku, drugaya v ogon', a tret'ya v ray…» Povestvovaniya o vere i spasenii staroobryadtsev Verkhokam'ya // O svoey zemle, svoey vere, nastoyashchem i perezhitom v Rossii XX–XXI vekov (k izucheniyu biograficheskogo i religioznogo narrativa). M.: Indrik, 2012. S. 49—167.
29. Suvorov N.S. O grazhdanskom brake. Yaroslavl', 1887. S. 90.
30. Suvorov N.S. Ob'em distsiplinarnogo suda i yurisdiktsii tserkvi v period vselenskikh soborov. Yaroslavl', 1884. S. 54.
31. Filippovskoe rodoslovie: istoricheskie sochineniya staroobryadtsev-filippovtsev Povolzh'ya i Yuzhnoy Vyatki. M.: Arkheodoksiya, 2004. 88 s.